I was one of the panel members at the Singapore Writers Festival symposium, The Business of Books, at The Arts House on the 6th and 7th of December. I travelled down by coach on the 6th by Aeroline (which, I must admit, was pretty comfortable) having declined an air ticket by the organisers. (Travelling to KLIA for short hauls is such a pain.) I didn't stay at their official hotel either because I have relatives in Singapore. (And besides I cannot bear to stay in a hotel full of writers. I managed to shock Shan and Saras -- and Saradha -- with the admission that I don't particularly like meeting writers.)
(I know several writers who are now my friends, and they are wonderful people let me assure you. With some people you connect and become friends, with others you don't. When we communicate we communicate as friends, like normal people. Don't you want to know the person behind the book you enjoyed so much, someone asked? No, not really. Orhan Pamuk says that he prefers to read books by dead writers 'so there is no little cloud of jealousy to cloud my admiration'. In my case, I would say 'so there is no little cloud of reality to mitigate my enjoyment' of the writing. Good example, VS Naipaul: I know many who simply can't sit back and enjoy his prose because of all the other things (they think) they know about him. For me it is the song not the singer, all the time. I used to hugely admire Led Zeppelin when in college. There was a reunion concert recently and I would have liked to attend for it would have been interesting to hear what they sound like now after all these years. Would I also have liked to meet one of them personally after the show, if it was at all possible? Not really. I have organised two Literary Festivals for Malaysians to meet the writers. I got a huge buzz, both times, out of seeing people enjoying the events, mixing and mingling with the authors. But, in both cases, I was not particularly interested in meeting any of them besides doing the obligatory handshake routine. Does that make sense?)
But I digress. I attended the Golden Point Awards ceremony on the night of the 5th, their annual literary awards ceremony. It was all very staid and respectable, unlike the elephants and lions we had for our opening ceremony. I prefer not to make any comment on the standards of the winners, though some of the translations on the screen were hilarious -- on par with the 'butterflies fondling' translation during a recent Chinese Opera performance in KL. But congratulations are due to the Singapore National Arts Council for organising the Writer’s Festival in four languages (though I didn't attend any of them). Having done it twice, I know what it would be like to organise something like that. But, of course, they had the backing of the government (which, I am sure, was not necessarily always helpful -- what with committees and all) and, with that, sponsors.
The symposium was run like clockwork, as we have come to expect of any event organised by Singapore, and there was not one 'ugly' Singaporean in sight. (Where did they get that reputation from, I sometimes wonder? In my dealings with them I have always found them extremely warm. Sometimes, I think Malaysians simply have a cultural need to bitch, or else I have met only the wrong (right?) type of Singaporean.) There were some interesting discussions at the symposium (despite there being no alcohol as any symposium, by definition, should) and some that were not. I was on the panel for two sessions -- one on (surprise) independent book publishing and another (again surprise) on organising Literary Festivals. One of the best attended was the one by literary agents and agencies, with many participants taking the opportunity to show off their self published books and one or two trying to sneak in a manuscript. Considering that the participants (around 50 pax) paid SGD 200.00 per day (or SGD 300.00 for two days) to attend the symposium, I guess they were entitled to at least that.
But the session on independent publishing threw up some interesting facts. While bookshops in the region carry tens of thousands of titles from the UK and the US they would, probably, carry less then ten titles each from neighbouring countries. Try looking for Indonesian, Filipino, Thai or Singaporean authors in any of the dozen or so ‘mega’ bookstores in KL. Ditto for Manila, Bangkok, Jakarta or Singapore. So much for 40 years of ASEAN. There is simply no name recognition of writers and, hence, no sales. Why is that so? Is it because regional writers are not glamorous enough?
Don't tell Ayu Utami or Laksmi Pamuntjak that.
Saturday, December 15, 2007
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Hi Raman,
ReplyDeleteYes, I do agree with a lot of what you say...discounting the fact that I did spot some of the newer published authors who appropriately looked nervous and felt out of place...until much later on. Madeline Thien confessed this to me herself. :-)
I found the Singaporeans to be extremely warm and friendly. It was amazing how eager the many established/aspiring authors were to exchange notes and make friends.
And the publisher of Ethos Books himself, was a decidedly humble gentleman.
I didn't know that writers had brought along their manuscripts to display to agents.
I remember in the late eighties and early nineties when it was a common sight to find Singapore literature in the vein of Claire Tham, playwright Ovidia Yu, Philip Jeyaratnam and aothers at local bookstores that included all the ones that closed down like Anthonian, Bookazine and also the delightful Kancilmas in Bangsar, run by an eternally-greying lady, Mrs. Tan.
But while sill not impossible, it's harder now. The only Malaysian literature I spotted in Kinokuniya, Tskashimaya was your newest edition of Silverfish and that's as far as it got in the section under Asian Literature.
In the heydays of the double-spread literary pages of the New Straits Times every Wednesday, its editor Kee Thuan Chye had the right balance running interviews on Singaporean writers including (the late Hillary Tham) together with Malaysian ones, current of the time.
But now, all that's gone.
Anyway, it was good meeting with you and you're right about the wine at the end...wasn't that heady top-class stuff? :-)
(I am publishing the comments below on behalf of Josephine. One question though: who is distributing Frog in this region?)
ReplyDeleteDear Raman,
For some reason I can't publish my comment on the website, it keeps telling me that my password is wrong so I am emailing it to you instead.
You are so right to say that generally people in Singapore feel that local writers are not as glamorous than foreign writers. I feel more of a writer here in west Sussex England than I do back home in Singapore because I'm not a big-time, best-seller author. I am in the local newspaper Chichester Obeserver, again this week and well-respected in writing circles here but in South East Asia, I'm practically dismissed! (Except by your Good Self who published a short story of mine. Perhaps you could review Frog Under A Coconut Shell which is selling well in UK?)
I also teach Creative Writing here in Uk though I know Creative Writing cannot be taught as such but if you are interested in me running a workshop or so I will come down. Will be in Singapore for October/November 2008.
All the best for the festive season and New Year!
Phine
Josephine Chia
West Sussex, England