 Malaysia needs a new
    historical narrative that can unite its people of diverse races, Tun
    Musa Hitam said at the launch of the 60th National History Summit,
    as was widely reported in the media. I don't think anyone would
    dispute that. Certainly, history cannot be only about winners and
    losers. “There is a historical combat in many countries," Tun Musa
    Hitam further said. I won't say 'many', I'd say every. Every country
    has historical disputes but, perhaps, none like Malaysia.
Malaysia needs a new
    historical narrative that can unite its people of diverse races, Tun
    Musa Hitam said at the launch of the 60th National History Summit,
    as was widely reported in the media. I don't think anyone would
    dispute that. Certainly, history cannot be only about winners and
    losers. “There is a historical combat in many countries," Tun Musa
    Hitam further said. I won't say 'many', I'd say every. Every country
    has historical disputes but, perhaps, none like Malaysia.Historians regard their job as a science and it should be. However, if only they were not human, nobody paid them, didn't take sides during wars and disputes, have no loyalty, no emotion, no belief system, and are totally and utterly objective. It has been argued that the myth of the battle of Agincourt, the centrepiece of Henry V by William Shakespeare, boosted the British national confidence, pride and ego to such an extent that it made them the most powerful colonial force in the history of the world, one that even the Roman's couldn't dream of. George Washington's apple tree incident is now disputed. More recently, in India, the Sethu Samudram project was put off because of a Hindu myth; Hanuman and his monkey horde won the court battle against the country's leading geologists and scientists.
In a battle between myth and history, the latter will always lose.
But Malaysia has another problem, one of credibility. People have no confidence in historians because they are assumed to be under the payroll of unseen forces, and therefore blatantly lie. So, no matter what version of history is written, it will be suspect. The main agenda of the 60th National History Summit should have been: How do we clean up the public image of Malaysian historians? Much of it is only perception, and patently untrue. But so what, if people think you are lying?
Everyone in the country wants history to be rewritten. But which version? Theirs. History only becomes accepted and acceptable when we are no longer afraid of the truth. Sure, everyone will call their version the truth, when it is merely a version of a lie. I will give you an example.
I get several customers in the shop who come looking for 'good' history books. One lady asked about one such recommendation, "Does it have Parameswara in it?" I said, "Yes," but I didn't add, "but that's not why it's good." She didn't look like someone who was clever, or non-poitical, enough to understand. For her, a good Malaysian history book must have Parameswara in it because she learnt that in school, or else the government was doing a fiddle.
Would it have made a difference if I had told her that Parameswara may not even been a name but a title, one of the four he had (according to some sources) in the fashion of Hindu rulers of the period? It was often difficult to say where titles ended and names began. Parameswara means the great lord from the words "param" meaning the highest and 'ishwara' meaning supreme being. (Yes, that's the reason many Hindus were sniggering when Proton decided to name a model of their car that.)
That entire problem was probably caused by Tome Pires, the apothecarist from Lisbon. In The Suma Oriental, he named the prince from Palembang, "Paramjcura which means the bravest man in the Palembang Javanese tongue." Why Javanese tongue? In all probability, it was of Indian/Hindu origin. (You can imagine a ruler assuming the role of the Great Lord, can't you?) Tome Pires went further to say that his wife was Paramjcure. Parameswari is the female equivalent, the great goddess, and our own Permaisuri probably comes from there. Winstead appears to have taken off from that, but stretched it a little more by suggesting that he was called Parameswara because he was a commoner who married a princess. Where did he get that? The Andayas' sources appear to have been the same too.
None of the versions of The Malay Annals I have read mention Parameswara. In Sedjarat Melayou translated by Devic and Starkweather, he is King Is Kender Chah. In Leyden's (often called Raffles') version, he is Raja Secander Shah. CC Brown calls him Sultan Iskandar Shah. Iskandar (after Alexander the Great) was the name of choice among many Malay kings. (Interestingly, Skanda is also another name for the South Indian god, Murugan, to put a cat among the pigeons.)
Tome Pires and Richard Winstead, and a host of others, were colonials, not professional historians. They were amateurs, albeit gifted and passionate. (Winstead was a civil servant). But their agenda was clearly colonial, and they made no attempts to hide where their loyalty lay. Their prejudice and lack of knowledge often showed glaringly in their writings. Still, let's not thrash their work summarily, lest we throw out the baby with the bath water. Let's not take their word as gospel either.
We still don't know the truth of many historical events and people, and we may never. A good historian must also be a linguist. However, in Malaysia it's not historical accuracy that is at stake, but credibility. Once a reputation (real or imaginary) for lying and manipulation has been established (and believed), it is difficult to turn it around. Historical errors might be due to plain incompetence, but try telling that to the people who are convinced that you are merely a stooge because you're constantly quoted in the 'wrong' newspapers.
So let the first agenda of the 61st National History Summit be: Rebuilding the credibility and dignity of the Malaysian Historian.

 
 
 Two stories in the media recently made me sit up. First, was a column in the New Straits Times
 (22 December, 2013) by one Awang Hitam about 'apartheid' in Malaysia, 
in which the writer accused non-Malay companies control the economy 
by of refusing entry and employment to Malays. Second, there was a story
 in The Malaysian Insider (23 December, 2013) about Ku Li's claim that Malays have only themselves to blame for their troubles.
Two stories in the media recently made me sit up. First, was a column in the New Straits Times
 (22 December, 2013) by one Awang Hitam about 'apartheid' in Malaysia, 
in which the writer accused non-Malay companies control the economy 
by of refusing entry and employment to Malays. Second, there was a story
 in The Malaysian Insider (23 December, 2013) about Ku Li's claim that Malays have only themselves to blame for their troubles. Two dear friends gave me a
    present recently -- a belated one for my birthday, or an early one
    for Christmas, I'm not sure. It was a Walker's Illustrated Classic
    edition of Gulliver. It is a gorgeous book indeed, and the
    illustrations by Chris Riddell are to die for. I first read
    Gulliver's Travels when I was a child, yes centuries ago. I was
    already an adult when I read the unabridged version. This Walker's
    edition brought back memories and an entirely new perspective.
Two dear friends gave me a
    present recently -- a belated one for my birthday, or an early one
    for Christmas, I'm not sure. It was a Walker's Illustrated Classic
    edition of Gulliver. It is a gorgeous book indeed, and the
    illustrations by Chris Riddell are to die for. I first read
    Gulliver's Travels when I was a child, yes centuries ago. I was
    already an adult when I read the unabridged version. This Walker's
    edition brought back memories and an entirely new perspective. Steve Jobs famously said,
    "Stay Hungry, Stay Foolish!" He also said, "Don’t let the noise of
    others’ opinions drown out your own inner voice. And most important,
    have the courage to follow your heart and intuition."
Steve Jobs famously said,
    "Stay Hungry, Stay Foolish!" He also said, "Don’t let the noise of
    others’ opinions drown out your own inner voice. And most important,
    have the courage to follow your heart and intuition." It
 was a pretty good haul
    this year, with requests for nearly thirty manuscripts from
    Germany, France, Italy and Turkey. Not to count chickens, but a 
two-and-a-half-dozen egg haul is pretty good considering the 'soft' book
 market, and small inquiries in the last two years. Isa Kamari, Farish A
 Noor, Rozlan
    Mohd Noor, and Shih-Li Kow were amongst the authors who attracted
    the most interest (and Shih-Li's new book has not even been
    published yet)! But, while Singapore's NAC provides translation
    grants, Malaysia does not (and certainly not for books in English),
    so Malaysian books might be slightly handicapped.
It
 was a pretty good haul
    this year, with requests for nearly thirty manuscripts from
    Germany, France, Italy and Turkey. Not to count chickens, but a 
two-and-a-half-dozen egg haul is pretty good considering the 'soft' book
 market, and small inquiries in the last two years. Isa Kamari, Farish A
 Noor, Rozlan
    Mohd Noor, and Shih-Li Kow were amongst the authors who attracted
    the most interest (and Shih-Li's new book has not even been
    published yet)! But, while Singapore's NAC provides translation
    grants, Malaysia does not (and certainly not for books in English),
    so Malaysian books might be slightly handicapped.  We received an email
    yesterday with the subject, "I am Alvin Tan, the man the media loves
    to hate." Yes, the same Alvin Tan who uploaded pictures of himself
    and his girlfriend on the internet and got into trouble in Singapore, and the 'buka
      puasa' photo, which got him into trouble in Malaysia. (The
    email was BCCed to Silverfish Books, so we assume he has sent it to
    other publishers as well.) He also sent several links to newspaper
    articles about the ... er ... his events, in case we didn't
    know who he is. I couldn't help but smile. It seemed like this guy
    now wants to make some money out of it all (maybe to pay his legal
    costs).
We received an email
    yesterday with the subject, "I am Alvin Tan, the man the media loves
    to hate." Yes, the same Alvin Tan who uploaded pictures of himself
    and his girlfriend on the internet and got into trouble in Singapore, and the 'buka
      puasa' photo, which got him into trouble in Malaysia. (The
    email was BCCed to Silverfish Books, so we assume he has sent it to
    other publishers as well.) He also sent several links to newspaper
    articles about the ... er ... his events, in case we didn't
    know who he is. I couldn't help but smile. It seemed like this guy
    now wants to make some money out of it all (maybe to pay his legal
    costs).  I had a meeting in
    Singapore recently with personnel of the National Arts Council
    over there. It appears that they liked some of the work Silverfish Books
    is doing and asked if we would collaborate on more projects in
    future. Of course, we'd like to collaborate, I said, but I'm very
    picky. I added that, to Silverfish Books, there was no such thing as
    'good enough'. If a work was considered'good enough' than it was not
    'good enough'. It is either good or bad. (My friend Joan told me
    that years ago.) There is simply no point in becoming champion of
    Subang Jaya.
I had a meeting in
    Singapore recently with personnel of the National Arts Council
    over there. It appears that they liked some of the work Silverfish Books
    is doing and asked if we would collaborate on more projects in
    future. Of course, we'd like to collaborate, I said, but I'm very
    picky. I added that, to Silverfish Books, there was no such thing as
    'good enough'. If a work was considered'good enough' than it was not
    'good enough'. It is either good or bad. (My friend Joan told me
    that years ago.) There is simply no point in becoming champion of
    Subang Jaya.  Not long ago (I think it was about 2 years) Amir had this story to
    tell. He was on a television talk-show with some others, and the
    host asked a guest, a local university professor type, who his
    favourite author was. A Samad Said, came the reply. Amir said he
    almost fell off his chair. (The good author might have been flattered, but mortified too.) Hasn't he read anything else?
    He told the host that his was Sufian Abas of Kasut Biru Rubina fame.
    There would be many who'd object to that anecdote indignantly with a
 'so what'. I have another story for that. A friend who claims that
    his favourite author is William Shakespeare, from whose work he'd 
spew quotes at the slightest provocation. He's weird, I used
    to think. Then, I learned that he had never read a play by the bard,
    not watched a performance. He, however, had memorised a book of
    quotes. Yes, you'd recognise him. He'd be the one trying to speak to
    the makcik selling pisang goreng at the night
    market in English or in really bad Malay!
Not long ago (I think it was about 2 years) Amir had this story to
    tell. He was on a television talk-show with some others, and the
    host asked a guest, a local university professor type, who his
    favourite author was. A Samad Said, came the reply. Amir said he
    almost fell off his chair. (The good author might have been flattered, but mortified too.) Hasn't he read anything else?
    He told the host that his was Sufian Abas of Kasut Biru Rubina fame.
    There would be many who'd object to that anecdote indignantly with a
 'so what'. I have another story for that. A friend who claims that
    his favourite author is William Shakespeare, from whose work he'd 
spew quotes at the slightest provocation. He's weird, I used
    to think. Then, I learned that he had never read a play by the bard,
    not watched a performance. He, however, had memorised a book of
    quotes. Yes, you'd recognise him. He'd be the one trying to speak to
    the makcik selling pisang goreng at the night
    market in English or in really bad Malay! 1. Train wrecks. Ah yes, A Fine Balance by
 Rohington Mistry was probably the first book I didn't bother to 
finish.  God, was it a train wreck?! One misery after another, it was 
relentless. I could here those mat sallehs going, "Oh, it's so-oo
 Indian." Yes, like a bad Indian movie! And I have seen enough of those 
as a kid. I gave up after the vasectomy turned castration scene 
(although I think I deserved a medal for even getting that far.)
1. Train wrecks. Ah yes, A Fine Balance by
 Rohington Mistry was probably the first book I didn't bother to 
finish.  God, was it a train wreck?! One misery after another, it was 
relentless. I could here those mat sallehs going, "Oh, it's so-oo
 Indian." Yes, like a bad Indian movie! And I have seen enough of those 
as a kid. I gave up after the vasectomy turned castration scene 
(although I think I deserved a medal for even getting that far.) This
 is not new, people have complained about copyright laws for a long 
time. Many customers coming into Silverfish asking for books published 
in the country in the 60s and 70s, which are now out of print. We would 
apologise and point them in the direction of antiquarian bookstores in 
London, and feel thoroughly stupid about it. These are Malaysian books, 
good books, and should be in print, even if only POD, and should be in 
the country.
This
 is not new, people have complained about copyright laws for a long 
time. Many customers coming into Silverfish asking for books published 
in the country in the 60s and 70s, which are now out of print. We would 
apologise and point them in the direction of antiquarian bookstores in 
London, and feel thoroughly stupid about it. These are Malaysian books, 
good books, and should be in print, even if only POD, and should be in 
the country. Step Two: Open Calibre.
    (The image shows what it would look like with all the
    books you have added. If you have not added any, you'll only see the
    Calibre Quick Start Guide.)
Step Two: Open Calibre.
    (The image shows what it would look like with all the
    books you have added. If you have not added any, you'll only see the
    Calibre Quick Start Guide.) When
 someone said (this was sometime ago) about one of our products,
    she didn't think Silverfish published 'that kind of book', we were
    gob-smacked. Our first reaction was, "What, what, what?!" as if we
    had been caught with our pant-zipper down. We were certainly
    confused. After we calmed, we asked ourselves, "Why did she think we
    wouldn't publish this?" It was quite obvious that she thought we 
were a bunch of snobs, but what kind?! It was important to ensure
    that one stood accused of the right type of snobbery. Then, we
    laughed.
When
 someone said (this was sometime ago) about one of our products,
    she didn't think Silverfish published 'that kind of book', we were
    gob-smacked. Our first reaction was, "What, what, what?!" as if we
    had been caught with our pant-zipper down. We were certainly
    confused. After we calmed, we asked ourselves, "Why did she think we
    wouldn't publish this?" It was quite obvious that she thought we 
were a bunch of snobs, but what kind?! It was important to ensure
    that one stood accused of the right type of snobbery. Then, we
    laughed.
 A news report in FMT on
    March 23 said that Berjaya Books Sdn Bhd, which owns the Borders
    bookstores in Malaysia, and two others today succeeded in their
    attempt to quash the decision by the Federal Territory Islamic
    Department (Jawi) over the seizure of Irshad Manji’s Allah, Kebebasan dan Cinta in May last year.
A news report in FMT on
    March 23 said that Berjaya Books Sdn Bhd, which owns the Borders
    bookstores in Malaysia, and two others today succeeded in their
    attempt to quash the decision by the Federal Territory Islamic
    Department (Jawi) over the seizure of Irshad Manji’s Allah, Kebebasan dan Cinta in May last year. Tash Aw was here in
    Silverfish Books to read from his latest (and third) book on
    February 23. Interestingly, Silverfish Books was the only bookshop
    he read at, although his KL tour was organised by MPH. Something
    like this would have been unthinkable just a year ago: an
    independent taking precedence over a mega-store. (But then, there
    are far fewer of those in the city now.) We believe Tash himself
    prefers to read in a cosy setting than in a 'supermarket aisle' of a
    big store, and he (apparently) told the organisers that. Still.
    Thank you, MPH, for giving us the privilege.
Tash Aw was here in
    Silverfish Books to read from his latest (and third) book on
    February 23. Interestingly, Silverfish Books was the only bookshop
    he read at, although his KL tour was organised by MPH. Something
    like this would have been unthinkable just a year ago: an
    independent taking precedence over a mega-store. (But then, there
    are far fewer of those in the city now.) We believe Tash himself
    prefers to read in a cosy setting than in a 'supermarket aisle' of a
    big store, and he (apparently) told the organisers that. Still.
    Thank you, MPH, for giving us the privilege.












